This is a 9 year Edradour selected by Binny’s that was matured in a Cotes Du Provence cask and bottled at 56.7% ABV.
Nose: Big pineapple juice notes up front before thick red wine notes overtake with dark chocolate covered berries and a buttery malt. The nose is a bit fleeting at times oddly enough – sometimes seeming quite hollow and distant.
Palate: The Cotes Du Provence notes lead off with loads of dark fruits: plums, black cherry, blackberries, etc. Some cocoa in there with just a bit of malt flavor coming through – mostly just wine dominant.
Finish: Dries out quickly as the wine notes fade – subtle sawdust and acetone notes are left over.
Rating: 80/100 – Tastes more like a wine than a malt at most times, but interesting if you like a very heavy maturation like that.
Value for the money: Guessing this retailed around $100 which is an ok price for something as unique as this.
This is a 10 year expression from the Ballechin (heavily peated) line from Edradour. It is a combination of ex-sherry and ex-bourbon cask maturations that’s bottled at 46% ABV.
Nose: Rubbery peat with strong new tennis ball artificial note – slight sherry comes through behind a salty malt.
Palate: New tennis ball note here again – very distracting as it has heavy chemical overtures. Strong peat with a watered down citrus note.
Finish: Peat lingers on with strong rubber notes.
Rating: 73/100 – I’ve had a few malts that have that new tennis ball note and each time I’ve found it highly distracting and oddly dominant.
Value for the money: This retails around $50 and it’s a pass for me.
This is a 14 year old Edradour expression that was finished in Oloroso casks and selected by Spec’s liquor in Texas.
Nose: Big, rich sherry notes up front – no mistaking the oloroso finish. Raisins, black cherries, brown sugar, and grape juice.
Palate: Bold, fruity delivery with lots of spice. Black cherry, anise, cherry cough drops, and cocoa.
Finish: Currants, cherries, and barley linger with a bit of cinnamon and honey.
Rating: 90/100 – Much better than the standard Edradour 10 – a great cask selection.
Value for the money: I think this retailed for $100 which I would pay for another bottle.